Disclaimer: The owners of this website may be paid to recommend Goldco or other companies. The content of this website, including any positive reviews of Goldco & other reviews, may not be neutral or independent. We may receive a commission from the companies we recommend. The content of this site is informational in nature and should not be relied upon without consulting an investment professional.

 

Augusta Precious Metals VS American Hartford Gold

Last Updated: May 15, 2025

There are many competitors in the world of gold investing, and deciding which one to seek can be challenging. When comparing Augusta Precious Metals and American Hartford Gold, it may feel like an apples-to-apples comparison, but the two have many differences. We are here to give you a complete comparison so you can decide.

Augusta Precious Metals and American Hartford Gold help customers invest in gold IRAs. American Hartford Gold is headquartered in Los Angeles, California, and Augusta Precious Metals is located in Casper, Wyoming.

What Is American Hartford Gold?

Sanford Mann launched American Hartford Gold in 2015, intending to sell IRA-approved precious metals. Since opening their doors, they have been well-known for their focus on customer service, something lacking in many of today’s gold companies.

They provide a range of options to help you invest in gold and silver. American Hartford Gold offers a no-pressure phone consultation to help you learn more about the company and your investing options. They guarantee to provide the lowest price among their competitors and have delivered over $1 billion in customer-purchased gold and silver products.

What Is Augusta Precious Metals?

Isaac Nuriani opened Augusta Precious Metals in 2012, so, as you can see, American Hartford Gold has been around just a little longer. The company believes in transparency throughout its operations. Devlyn Steele is the Director of Education for Augusta Precious Metals. He is well-respected in the gold industry and will provide educational materials to help you determine your best investment approach.

You can purchase physical gold and silver from Augusta. Have your precious metals delivered to your door or shipped directly to your chosen depository.

Augusta Precious Metals VS American Hartford Gold Comparison Chart:

American Hartford Gold Augusta Precious Metals
Year Company Founded 2015 2012
BBB Rating A+ A+
Trustpilot Rating 4.9 (1154 Reviews) 4 (4 Reviews)
Minimum Investment $10,000 $50,000
No Penalty Roll Overs Yes Yes
Buy Back Program Yes Yes
Recommended By Sean Hannity Joe Montana
Up to $10K in Free Silver Yes Yes
Free Shipping Yes Yes
Low Price Guarantee Yes No
Call in Phone Consultation 855-665-0957 No
Read Detailed Review American Hartford Gold Review Augusta Precious Metals Review

American Hartford Gold: What Do They Offer?

American Hartford Gold is all about convenience and works to help its customers invest in gold and silver quickly. They will help you diversify your investment portfolio to protect your retirement investments. They will assist you in rolling over your current retirement account to a gold IRA.

They will provide options to help you invest in bars and coins approved for gold IRAs. They treat you like you are their only customer. The one-on-ones you receive will guide you in making the right decisions.

Augusta Precious Metals: What Do They Offer?

Augusta Precious Metals also helps you roll over your retirement account to a gold IRA. Just like American Hartford Gold, they guide you in your decisions. They also offer premium gold at a fair market price.

Augusta Precious Metals is devoted to educating its customers, and they consistently produce educational materials to help their customers gain experience and understanding in the world of investing in gold and silver.

What Fees Does American Hartford Gold Charge?

We are all worried about money these days, so it stands to reason you want to know about the fees. We have discovered American Hartford Gold is one of the most affordable in the industry.

They charge an annual fee for managing your account based on size. Unlike many in the industry, they do not charge a fee for opening your account. You will pay a $180 yearly fee. This fee goes to your custodian. You may pay more if you choose segregated storage. Hartford Gold likes to use the Delaware Depository for its customer storage options.

What Fees Does Augusta Precious Metals Charge?

You must pay $250 to open your account with Augusta Precious Metals. You will also need to pay $200 a year, which includes a custodian fee and storage fee. The minimum investment amount is $50,000.

As you can already tell, American Hartford Gold is winning in the fees department. If you want to save money, American Hartford Gold is your best choice, but there is much more to discover.

What Precious Metal Products Does American Hartford Gold Offer?

American Hartford Gold offers a broad range of gold products to help you invest in a gold IRA. The following are some of the offerings on their website.

  • Australian Wildlife Coin
  • They have partnered with professional custodians who can help you open a gold IRA or rollover from your retirement account.

What Precious Metal Products Does Augusta Precious Metals Offer?

Aside from helping customers invest in gold and silver for their precious metals IRAs, the company also offers a wide array of products for personal investment. You can purchase through their website or call by phone. Here, you will find some of the best offerings from the company.

     
  • Gold American Eagle 1-Ounce
  • Gold American Eagle .5 Ounce
  • Gold American Eagle .25 Ounce
  • Gold American Eagle .10 Ounce
  • American Silver Eagle 1-Ounce
  • Canadian Silver Maple Leaf
  • Austrian Philharmonic Silver
  • Silver Round 1-Ounce
  • Rose Crown Guinea.
  • Both gold companies have a wealth of selections to help you start investing. Both companies appear helpful in guiding investors through the process. Each company especially helps new investors get started without fear.

How Does American Hartford Gold Compare to Others in the Industry?

In addition to comparing Augusta Precious Metals Vs. American Hartford Gold, we also want you to know how each gold company compares to others in the industry. One thing that makes American Hartford Gold stand out is its 100% focus on customer service. For instance, they have a 100% customer response rating on the Better Business Bureau.

American Hartford Gold also guarantees they have the lowest gold prices in the industry. They stand behind this promise. Although no company is without complaints, American Hartford Gold has one of the best customer ratings in the industry, and they work to resolve issues quickly.

How Does Augusta Precious Metals Compare to Others in the Industry?

Augusta Precious Metals stands out from the rest because of its commitment to educating customers. They genuinely want to help and do not pressure people to buy gold and silver products.

They also work to provide a lifetime of support to their loyal customers. The company has a solid customer rating, with an A+ rating on the Better Business Bureau.

Industry Experience: American Hartford Gold or Augusta Precious Metals?

Both gold companies employ experts that are well-versed in investing in gold IRAs. American Hartford Gold has been around just a few more years. Have these few years given them an advantage over Augusta Precious Metals?

When investing in precious metals IRAs, you want someone who has helped as many investors as possible. Statistics say American Hartford Gold has served more investors simply because of their extra years in business.

American Hartford Gold Ratings & Reviews

American Hartford Gold has been accredited by the Better Business Bureau since 2016. They currently have 4.91 stars out of five for their customer rating on the BBB. The company has an A+ rating. They have 22 complaints that have all been closed in the last three years.

American Hartford Gold has thousands of five-star reviews. Many customers are happy with the customer service and products they receive.

Augusta Precious Metals Ratings & Reviews

Augusta Precious Metals has been accredited by the Better Business Bureau since 2015. They have had no formal complaints lodged on the BBB website. Currently, Augusta Precious Metals has an A+ rating. Their current star rating is 4.93 out of 5 stars. They, too, have thousands of complaints from happy customers.

Our Final Verdict: Which Company Is Best?

We have given you a lot of information regarding Augusta Precious Metals Vs. American Hartford Gold. Although both companies offer stellar customer service and valuable precious metal products for gold IRA investments, there is one company that slightly stands out as best.

American Hartford Gold has more experience serving investors than Augusta Precious Metals. They also offer lower prices on their fees because they do not charge a fee to open your account.

We urge you to research to learn as much as possible about each company and make an informed decision. Allow the information we have shared here to launch your search.

The Best Gold & Silver Companies of 2025

#1: Best For All Level Investors

American Hartford Gold

5 Star customer service, easy to work with, and a low price guarantee.

#2: Best For $50,000+ Investors

Goldco

Excellent customer service from precious metals experts.

#3: Best For $25,000+ Investors

Birch Gold

High level of customer service and a solid reputation

Noble Gold

High level of customer service and a solid reputation

Augusta Precious Metals

Earned best overall gold IRA company of 2022 by Investopedia's most transparent.
SEE APM PROMOTIONS >
Full Review